TERRAIN TRAPS AND THE HUMAN FACTOR
11 min · Free lesson · written lesson, video in production
After this lesson you can separate how likely a slide is from what it would do to you, name the thinking traps that catch strong, well equipped parties, and build a group culture where calling it off costs nothing.
The Technique
- A terrain trap is any feature that turns a small slide into a serious one. Gullies and creek beds that funnel and stack debris deep. Benches, road cuts and lips where moving snow piles up on itself. Trees, rocks and stumps that cause trauma before burial ever matters. Cliffs and ice below the runout. Flat, tight runouts where the debris has nowhere to spread. The same volume of snow that would push you over in an open apron will bury you over your head in a creek bed. The snow did not change. The container did.
- Consequence mapping is a separate judgement from stability, and it is the one most parties skip. For every pitch, ask what is above you, what is below you, what the snow does if it moves, where it stops, and how deep it ends up. Then ask the harder question: if it moves and I go with it, what is the realistic outcome. Terrain where the answer is "a rough ride and a walk out" is a different sport from terrain where the answer is "trees" or "over the lip". You can accept a higher chance of a slide on the first and none at all on the second.
- Small features kill people. The slope that is too short to be worth naming, the roll above the road, the little pitch you cross to get to the good stuff: they produce the accidents because nobody treats them as terrain. Trigger points are not always under your tyres or edges either. Slopes connect, snow propagates, and you can pull a slab down on yourself from below or from a flat bench beside it. If you are standing in the runout of something that can move, you are exposed even if you never touch the start zone.
- Now the harder half. Avalanche accidents are not usually the work of ignorant people. They involve fit, equipped, experienced parties who have done courses and carry the gear. The gap is almost never between what people know and what is true. It is between what they know and what they decide when they are tired, keen, running late, in front of a camera, or standing beside someone they want to impress. Treat your own decision making as an unreliable instrument that needs external checks, the same way you treat a compass near a snowmobile.
- Learn the traps by name so you can catch yourself using one. Familiarity: we ride this every winter and it has always been fine, which is a statement about the past and not about today's snowpack. Commitment: we said we would ride this line, we drove all night, we booked the machines. Social proof: there are tracks on it, so somebody else already decided for us. The expert halo: the strongest rider went first, or someone in the group is treated as the guide and nobody wants to question them, and sometimes that person is you and nobody has told you they are uneasy. Scarcity: first tracks, last day, the light is going, it will be tracked out by tomorrow. And acceptance: riding for the approval of the group, which gets sharper in mixed parties and sharper again when a camera is running.
- Groups do not average out individual judgement, they distort it. Responsibility spreads until nobody feels they own the call. Silence reads as agreement when it is usually just discomfort. The loudest and most confident voice sets the tone before the careful voices have formed a sentence. People who would never ride a slope alone will ride it in company because everyone else looks calm, and everyone else looks calm because they are watching you. The classic accident debrief has half the party saying afterwards that they had a bad feeling and said nothing.
- Build the culture deliberately, before the season, in the car park, out loud. Anyone can call it off, any time, with no reason required and no discussion afterwards, and the person who calls it gets thanked in front of the group rather than argued with. Give each rider their own opinion before they hear anyone else's: at a decision point, everyone states their call at the same time or writes it down, so the first speaker does not set the answer. Rotate a devil's advocate whose actual job for the day is to argue the other side. Name your decision points at the trailhead and name what would send you to plan B, then hold your own rule when you get there.
- Two questions do a lot of work in the field. The first is "what would have to be true for this to be a bad idea", which forces the party to argue against the plan rather than for it, and which surfaces the observations people have been quietly sitting on. The second is "what are we doing that we would not do if the camera was off, or if the guide were watching, or if we were on our own out here". Ask both at the top of anything consequential. If the answers make anyone go quiet, that silence is data.
Common Mistakes
Treating the danger rating as the whole decision and the terrain as a detail. Fix: the rating tells you how likely, the terrain tells you what happens to you. Do the consequence map for every pitch, and let a bad consequence veto a good stability picture.
- Asking the group "everyone happy" and reading silence as consent. Fix: ask each person by name for their call, and ask the least experienced or least senior first, before the loud voices have shaped the room.
The Drill
The independent call. At three decision points on every trip, each rider writes their go or no go and one line of reasoning on their phone before anyone speaks, then you read them out. Standard: run it for a full season and keep the notes. If the group's action ever differs from the majority of the private calls, you have found your human factor and you name it in the debrief that night. The party is working when at least one private doubt visibly changes the plan.
This lesson is about judgement, and judgement is the part of avalanche work that written material is worst at teaching. It comes from field days with a qualified instructor, terrain time with someone more experienced than you, and honest debriefs after the days that went sideways. Take a certified avalanche course, then take the next one up. Nothing on this page is a substitute for that training or for a professional guide in serious terrain.
LET'S BUILD
YOUR
ADVENTURE
Whether you want to surf Japan's legendary powder, ride the Old Telegraph Track to the tip of Cape York, or chase a New Zealand winter - tell us what you're dreaming about and we'll build the trip around you.